| Price | KWG Score | |
| 1. Antinori 2016 "Tignanello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $130 | 96.5 (6 reviews) |  |
| 2. Antinori 2015 "Tignanello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $135 | 96.1 (6 reviews) | |
| 3. Isole e Olena 2016 "Cepparello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $94 | 95.6 (5 reviews) | |
| 4. Biserno 2018 "Biserno" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $178 | 95.2 (4 reviews) | |
| 5. Isole e Olena 2014 "Cepparello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $85 | 95 (3 reviews) | |
| 6. Isole e Olena 2017 "Cepparello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $99 | 95 (4 reviews) | |
| 7. Mazzei 2018 "Siepi" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $130 | 94.8 (4 reviews) | |
| 8. Luce della Vite 2010 "Luce" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $93 | 94.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 9. Monteverro 2015 "Flagship" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $125 | 94.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 10. Sette Ponti 2020 "Oreno" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $130 | 94.5 (4 reviews) | |
| 11. Argiano 2016 "Brunello di Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $75 | 94 (6 reviews) | |
| 12. Biserno 2017 "Biserno" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $200 | 94 (4 reviews) | |
| 13. Argiano 2015 "Solengo" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $85 | 93.6 (3 reviews) | |
| 14. Isole e Olena 2011 "Cepparello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $90 | 93.6 (5 reviews) | |
| 15. Querciabella 2004 "Camartina" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $110 | 93.6 (5 reviews) | |
| 16. Luce della Vite 2011 "Luce" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $105 | 93.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 17. Isole e Olena 2015 "Cepparello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $90 | 93.3 (3 reviews) | |
| 18. Brancaia 2004 "Il Blu" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $90 | 93 (3 reviews) | |
| 19. Poggio al Tesoro 2015 "Bolgheri Superiore Sondraia" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $85 | 92.8 (6 reviews) | |
| 20. Monteverro 2016 "Tinata" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $110 | 92.6 (3 reviews) | |
| 21. Argiano 2017 "Solengo" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $80 | 92.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 22. Castello Banfi 2006 "Poggio Alle Mura Brunello de Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $82 | 92.4 (5 reviews) | |
| 23. Luce della Vite 2014 "Luce" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $125 | 92.3 (3 reviews) | |
| 24. Luce della Vite 2017 "Luce" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $135 | 92.3 (3 reviews) | |
| 25. Antinori 2001 "Tignanello" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $80 | 92.2 (4 reviews) | |
| 26. Castello Banfi 2007 "Poggio Alle Mura Brunello de Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $82 | 92.2 (5 reviews) | |
| 27. Cortonesi 2015 "La Mannella Brunello di Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $75 | 92 (6 reviews) | |
| 28. Monteverro 2017 "Terra di Monteverro" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $75 | 92 (1 review) | |
| 29. Monteverro 2009 "Toscana" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $175 | 91.5 (2 reviews) | |
| 30. Frescobaldi 2012 "Castelgiocondo Brunello di Montalcino" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $79 | 91.4 (5 reviews) | |
| 31. Poggio al Tesoro 2014 "Bolgheri Superiore Sondraia" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $75 | 91 (2 reviews) | |
| 32. Avignonesi 2011 "Grandi Annate Vino Nobile di Montepulciano" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $80 | 91 (3 reviews) | |
| 33. Brancaia 2008 "Il Blu" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $85 | 91 (3 reviews) | |
| 34. Luce della Vite 2008 "Luce" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $92 | 91 (2 reviews) | |
| 35. Luce della Vite 2003 Italian (Tuscany) Red | $75 | 90.7 (4 reviews) | |
| 36. Monteverro 2009 "Terra di Monteverro" Italian (Tuscany) Red | $80 | 90.5 (2 reviews) | |
